The Other Sister by Sarah Zettel [Book Review]

Book Review

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. For more info, read my Disclosure Policy.


Title: The Other Sister

Author: Sarah Zettel

Publisher: Grand Central Publishing

Publish Date: August 28, 2018

Genre: Psychological Thriller

Series: na

My Rating: 3/5

The Other Sister by Sarah Zettel


Two sisters. One murder plan.
Everyone thought reckless, troubled Geraldine Monroe was the bad sister — especially when she fled town after her mother’s death twenty-five years ago.
But people don’t know the truth.
Marie Monroe knows. She was there for their father’s cruel punishments, the constant manipulation, the lies. Everyone thinks she’s the perfect daughter — patient and kind, and above all obedient. No one would suspect her of anything. Especially not murder.
Now Geraldine’s home again, and she and Marie have united in a plan for the ultimate revenge. But when old secrets and new fears clash, everyone is pushed to the breaking point . . . and the sisters will learn that they can’t trust anyone-not even each other.

The Other Sister by Sarah Zettel


Geraldine and Marie’s mother died over twenty years ago, and Geraldine left shortly after her death. Their mother was an alcoholic, and Geraldine spent a good deal of time taking care of her. Though Geraldine left, Marie stayed in town and helped her father with the home and business. The father, Martin, was cruel and controlling. The home life of the girls was less than ideal, though they put up a good front that things were better than they appeared. Many years have passed, but with Geraldine back in town, old wounds are reopening

Geraldine is back in town for her nephew’s graduation, and it looks like she’ll be staying for a while. Her sister, Marie, is happy to have Geraldine back, but their father, Martin, is suspicious of Geraldine’s reasons for being in town.

The Other Sister uses alternating points of view, plus multiple timelines. Most of the story takes place in present day, but a good deal of the book is devoted to flashbacks of when the women were young girls and teens. I found the alternating points of view to be fine, but the alternating timelines were not as well done. The story lost focus and too much was happening.

I did enjoy the excerpts of Geraldine’s book on fairytales that she is writing. Her excuse for staying in town is because she is writing a book, and her field of study is fairytales. This added to the atmosphere of the story, and gave it a little bit of an eerie feel.

The story about the sisters is intriguing. They have difficult pasts and uncertain futures. The Other Sister was more of a slow burn story, but things do pick up toward the end of the book. Dark, convoluted, and treacherous.

Books by Sarah Zettel:
  1. The Other Sister
  2. A Mother’s Lie

9 thoughts on “The Other Sister by Sarah Zettel [Book Review]

  1. This is a little bit like Roses and Rot. Two sisters get accepted in a prestigious art school- one a writer the other a dancer. While things look normal on the outside, its the inside that is strange. The book is about the fae. You will like it. Unfortunately, I didn’t review this one but it’s good. Not YA

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.